General Criteria
|
 | Your Attack against TFP's Book Is Wrong!
The editor responds to objections over his review of TFP's Pandora Box
|
| What Is Your Take on the True & False Right?
Explanation of what false right is & the example of Bishop Schneider
|
| Why Are TIA's Authors Boycotted by Other Traditionalists?
Read on the distinction between false-right, 5th column & common thieves
|
| Are Jesuits the Veiled Power in the Church?
They have a great role, we have dealt with good and bad Jesuits - read here
|
SSPX
|
|
Does the SSPX Say the Dialogue Mass?
Yes, it does. Read the testimony of Msgr. Patrick Perez
|
| Is TIA Sede-Vacantist or in Support of the SSPX?
TIA is neither sede-vacantist nor linked to the SSPX
|
| Is TIA Part of the St. Pius X Movement? – Another Similar Question
No, we are not
|
| If You Are Not SSPX, What Branch of Traditionalism Do You Support?
TIA does not support branches, but Catholic principles
|
| Does the Schism of SSPX Make Its Previous Sacraments Invalid?
No, it does not
|
| Are SSPX Confessions & Masses Valid even without Jurisdiction?
We believe they are; Faith has precedence over jurisdiction
|
| How Can SSPX Administer the Sacraments without Jurisdiction?
To assist the preeminent needs of the lay people
|
| What Are the Alternatives to SSPX in view of Its Compromise?
You can assist at Eastern Rite Masses that still maintain their old liturgies
|
| Given the SSPX Compromise, Should I Go to Another Mass? Where?
Even compromised, its Sacraments are valid; other possibilities are here
|
| Are the Sacraments Administered by Bishop Galarreta Valid?
Yes, they are. Do not worry about that
|
| Outcast with the SSPX & the FSSP
They have valid sacraments, but we must resist Progressivism
|
| Should I Go to SSPX, FSSP or SPV Masses?
Here are the pros & cons; it is up to you to decide
|
| The SSPX Uses the '62 Missal, Are there Valid Alternatives?
The '62 Missal is still valid and here is why
|
| Why Do SSPX Priests Always Impose the 'Just Pray & Obey'?
To bring as many people as they can to the merge - see previous answer
|
| What Does TIA Think about the SSPX-Rome Negotiations?
We believe the Bishops are preparing the faithful to accept a merge
|
| Do You Believe SSPX Will Actually Compromise?
In theory, Fellay can step back; in practice, it seems the deal is made
|
| Why Is TIA Silentt on the SSPX Merger with Progressivism?
TIA has not been silent. Here is the list of our comments
|
| Can Mr. Guimarães Comment on the SSPX Vatican Situation?
A compromnise will oblige it to accept the Vatican II & the New Mass
|
| Have You Seen the Compromise on the SSPX Website?
No, we have not. Thank you for your opportune comments
|
| Will Pope Francis Use the SSPX to Quarantine Traditionalism?
A future merger will leave only a fragment to resist
|
| Is Bishop Williamson Safe to Follow?
Bishop Williamson is in the game to control anti-compromise reactions
|
| Why Did Card. Royos Say Bishop Fellay Accepted Vatican II?
Probably because Fellay did; check the consequences of a merge here
|
| Did You Read What Bishop Fellay Wrote about Your Criticism?
You can find our answer to him in this page
|
| Aren't You Losing Friends Because of Your Criticism of Fellay?
Our real friends are those who want to follow the truth without compromise
|
| Why Did You Offend the Ladies Who Forwarded Fellay's Letter?
It seems your sensibilities are more delicate than the ladies'
|
| Did You Read the Documents Confirming Your Warning about Fellay?
Thank you for sending them – we are publishing them here for our readers
|
| Why Didn't Priests Leaving SSPX Present Evidence against Fellay?
They did, but TIA did not translate all the documents
|
| What about the Priory of Sion & Its Links with Lefebvre?
Here are the allegations, which oscillate between speculation & probability
|
| Could You Clarify Why Fr. Meramo Was Expelled?
Find a summary of what happened here
|
| Is SSPX Making Concessions to Buddhism?
Here is close-up of a chapel in Tokyo showing ‘inculturation’
|
| The Tokyo 'Space' Is Not a Chapel; Can't You See That?
Angelus magazine calls it a chapel, here are the original sources
|
| Can't You See It Is Just a Rented Place without Chairs?
SSPX has been there for 8 years & there are signs of inculturation
|
| Do You Know that SSPX Is Supporting Dorothy Day?
No, we did not. Thank you for the information
|
| Did You See The Angelus & Fr. Scott Attacked You for Attacking Gill?
Yes, we did; here is our refutation
|
| Why Is an SSPX Priest Accusing TIA of Sede-Vacantism?
This priest is wrong. It is obvious that we are not sede-vacantists
|
|
What Is Your Opinion on the Presence of SSPX in Quito - 2019?
Here is TIA final balance on this presence
|
FSSP, IGS, FSJV & ICKSS
|
| How Can You Prove the Fraternity of St. Peter Is Compromised?
It has the Bishops' approval, which only happens with the acceptance of Vatican II
|
| Is the FSSP Alright to Say the Gregorian 30 Masses?
The FSSP has valid Masses for the Gregorian 30
|
| Is this Particular FSSP Alright to Attend?
We need more information, but here are some general guidelines
|
| Was Fr. Bisig the True Successor of Arch. Lefebvre?
If he says this, it is better to ask him to prove it, not us
|
| Can You Give Your Opinion on the Institute of Christ the King?
It is a compromised organization that seeks to please Progressivism
|
| Can I Get Back a Contract I signed with Institute of Christ the King?
If the ICRSS forgot it tricked you it may be best to let it go
|
| What Is Your Opinion on the Institute of Good Shepherd?
Read here how it has been strangled by the Vatican
|
| What Is Your Take on Bishop Rifan's Adhesion to the Novus Ordo Mass?
See his position and his apologia for the New Mass here
|
| Can We Say that Bishop Rifan Is a Traitor?
Yes we can, the proof is here
|
| Why Do You Say Fr. Rifan Was In the SSPX Cupola When He Was Not?
One of the highest authorities of the SSPX confirmed that he was
|
| Can We Say Rifan Is a Forerunner of Fellay?
Read Fellay's criticism of Rifan & see whether the former is on the same path
|
Distributism
|
| Why Do So Many Traditionalists Support Distributism?
It is a way to divert attention from the fight against Progressivism
|
| Is Distributism Being Spread among Traditionalists to Destroy Them?
Yes, you are right; it is the scatter and divide tactic
|
| Is Distributism Catholic?
No, it is based not on the Popes but on Marx
|
| Can We Say Distributism Is a Masked Socialism?
Yes, we can; it explains Distributism perfectly
|
| What Is Your Take on Eric Gill, Founder of Distributism?
He was a morally corrupt man & a precursor of Vatican II
|
| Gill's Vices Don't Affect Distributism. Aren't Diamonds in the Mud?
The right metaphor is: The bad tree gives bad fruits; not that of diamonds
|
| Is Gill Bad or Good? Pros & Cons in a SSPX Forum
Defenses, objections, replies & critiques regarding Eric Gill
|
| Who Gave You the Right to Reproduce the Comments of Our Forum?
They were in the public domain; they were about our articles; we reproduced them
|
| Did You Not Sin against Charity in Exposing Gill & His Vices?
No, we did not; we exposed a criminal for the sake of the public good
|
| Why Do You Attack Gill's Art? His Art Is Not Connected to His Vices
We only attack his art insofar as his vices are present in it
|
| Weren't the Founders of Distributism Chesterton & Belloc & not Gill?
These socialists leaders were all founders, but Gill was the principal one
|
| What Do You Think about Hilaire Belloc?
He was a liberal disguised in traditionalist robes
|
| Were Chesterton & Tolkien also Bad?
We plan to study Chesterton - Tolkien was not linked to Distributism
|
| Why Are You Condemning Belloc & Chesterton by Association?
Odou is not doing this; he is studying each one individually
|
| Was Arthur Penty as Good as Many People Say?
His teachings are analyzed here, here & here
|
| What about the Other Great Thinkers of Distributism?
They hold the same position as the ones we quoted
|
| Can I Translate Your Articles to Fight Distributism?
Yes, you can; here are the conditions
|
Nazism, Fascism etc.
|
| What Is the Counter-Revolutionary Stance on Nazism/Fascism?
They are against Catholic doctrine & follow a Gnostic theory
|
| Is Nazism a Movement of the Left or the Right?
It is a false right to direct anti-communists to Socialism
|
| What Is Your Position on Nazism?
It is a Gnostic-Manichean sect; read this series
|
| Did You See the Southern Poverty Law Center Attacked You?
Yes, we did; here is our refutation
|
| What Was Your Readers' Reaction over the SPLC Attack against TIA?
Readers reacted with indignation in our favor
|
| Can You Cite a Good Catholic Reaction to Nazism?
Yes, we can; here is an overview of a reaction by Baroness von Guttenberg
|
| Have the Nazis Practiced Euthanasia?
Yes, they have; read Card. von Gallen's heroic reaction against it here & here
|
| Was the Priory of Sion a Nazi Order?
We don't know; you can come to your own conclusions reading this report
|
| Is It True that Belloc Admired Mussolini?
Yes, he was an adept of Mussolini & Fascism
|
| Does Modern Art Have Any Link with Nazism?
Yes, it does; read here what is behind Futurism & Surrealism
|
| Are There Other Movements Similar to Nazism?
Yes, Fascism, Petainism, Francoism, Salazarism, Integralism are some of them
|
Card. Ottaviani, Siri, Newman & Arch. Sheen
|
| Did Cardinal Ottaviani Accept Progressivism?
Yes, he did; check this document here
|
| I Have Heard Ottaviani Supported the U.N. Is It True?
Yes, he did; read his declaration
|
| Can't You See that Ottaviani Didn't Accept Progressivism? You Are Wrong
Your document does not address the point you imagine
|
| Why Don't You Promote the Siri Thesis?
Because it is wrong. Read here.
|
| Wasn't Card. Siri Elected Pope & Forced into Seclusion?
He publicly denied any support for those who consider him pope
|
| Did Card. Siri Accept the Conciliar Popes?
Yes, he did, check these links here, here & here
|
| Can You Present Proof Siri Said the New Mass?
Yes, here you have some photos of him saying the Novus Ordo Mass
|
| Do You Have Solid Evidence Proving Newman Was a Liberal?
Yes, we do, read this series of documents taken from his works
|
| Why Do You Say Newman Was a Liberal?
Because he in fact was one, as proved here
|
| Is It Certain that Newman Opposed Pius IX?
Yes, it is, read here, here & here
|
| What Do You Think about Newman's Beatification?
We believe he was not a saint; read here, here & here
|
| Do You Have Any Article by Brownson against Newman?
Yes, he wrote a book against Newman; here is a review of it
|
| Did Fr. Feeney Ever Attack Newman?
Yes, we published one of his attacks here
|
| Were the Newman Centers Named After Newman or Neumann?
After Card. John Henry Newman, the Liberal
|
| Is It True Newman Never Completely Converted?
Yes, he continued to defend Anglicanism all his life
|
| Was Newman a Homosexual?
It is not certain, but there are many symptoms he was; read here, here & here
|
| Is It Sure that Newman's Body Was Completely Pulverized?
Yes, when his grave was opened, neither bones nor teeth were left
|
| How Dare you Accuse Newman of Homosexuality?!
It is because there are evidence of both his heresy & perversity
|
| Are there Studies on Newman's Epistemology?
Yes, a book by Orestes Brownson & many documents taken from his biography
|
| Fulton Sheen is Often Pictured with Protestants. Was He Ecumenical?
Yes, he was an early promoter of interfaith meetings and talks
|
| Was Arch. Sheen a Socialist of Some Sort?
He defended a notion of co-ownership very similar to that of Socialism
|
| Was Fulton Sheen Favorable to the New Mass & Vatican II?
Yes, he was an enthusiast of the Council and said the New Mass
|
| Is It True That Fulton Sheen Admired Teilhard de Chardin?
Yes, in his biography he spends a chapter defending Chardin
|
| What About Sheen's Cause of Beatification?
It was suspended; read here
|
| Why Do You Judge Sheen for His Hand Gestures?
We don't; we studied his doctrine, not gestures
|
| What Do You Think about a Miracle Attributed to Newman?
We don't trust the new criteria for miracles adopted by the Conciliar Church
|
| Is It True that Sheen Died in Swimtrunks on a Beach?
We have not heard of it; it seems unlikely
|
