No, thanks

 

the Conclave

 

Movie Review
donate Books CDs HOME updates search contact

The Donkey Steals the Show

Film review of The Star, directed by Timothy Reckart, 2017

Christina Herath, Sri Lanka
sTAR
As the Nativity season approaches, parents today will be interested in good, solid Christmas movies to entertain their children and foment in them the pious and joyous spirit of Christmas. Therefore, it is important to know which movies do the very opposite.

Today, sadly, we review another example of a bad Christmas movie – The Star (2017).

In an interview, the producer Devon Franklin stated: "I do believe The Star can bring peace to families and can bring hope to everyone who sees it to know that there is joy in the world, that through community, through faith, through love, we can make it through anything".

From his words, we can already realize how this movie will have nothing supernatural in it, and rather will embrace the Protestant idea of Christianity being merely a community where everyone is nice to each other and happy.

Watching the movie, it becomes very clear that there are more serious errors than a mere progressivist retelling of the Biblical account. With this brief introduction, we proceed to outline the major errors of the movie.

Main focus is animals

One major error of The Star is the fact that its main focus is neither the Christ Child nor His Blessed Mother. If the movie succeeds in one thing, it is making Christ Himself a side character in His own story of the Birth of the Man-God.

animals
The main protagonist instead is a little mill donkey that dreams of breaking free from its dreary life and joining the royal caravan. His dove friend, Dave, who can also talk – like all the animals in this film – is his accomplice in this endeavor.

After escaping the mill one day and being chased through the town by an angry miller, the little donkey hides in the yard of the "newlyweds" Mary and Joseph. Mary, who is portrayed in this movie like so many others as just a nice girl, feels sorry for the poor animal, nurses his wounded leg and names him Boaz, Bo for short.

With this Bo and his group of animal friends enter center stage and become the “unsung heroes” of the Nativity. They rescue Mary and Joseph from Herod’s henchman and dogs, and, in the end, assure the safe Birth of the Infant Jesus.

Biblically inaccurate

When it comes to loyalty to the biblical account of the Birth of Christ, the movie has none. The film takes so much creative freedom that it will confuse the viewer, especially the little children to whom it is marketed.

mary
For instance, the Annunciation is stripped of everything that made the event mysterious and wonderful. The Angel Gabriel appears as light and stardust – more magic than supernatural. Then, the dialogue between the two is completely altered and makes Mary seem confused and awkward instead of the Handmaid of the Lord as the Gospel recounts.

“Do I say thank you?... let it be done as you said," she mumbles, before Gabriel flashes out of her room and then becomes the star that supposedly guides the wise men to Bethlehem. Again, completely inaccurate, since the star was not an angel but a real star and did not actually appear until the Christ Child was born to guide the Three Kings to the stable in Bethlehem.

The movie mixes up the Visitation as well: In fact, there simply is no Visitation as traditionally presented by Scriptures and Tradition. Instead, the girl Mary arrives at her wedding to Joseph six months after the Annunciation. A disgusting side note is that the marriage is portrayed after the Conception, which is offensive to Our Lady and tries to justify girls to become pregnant before the marriage.

Elizabeth and Zachariah are only guests at the feast. Of course, there is no “Blessed art thou amongst all women…”. It is a simple and quick exchange of words between Elizabeth and Mary, before Elizabeth and Zachariah rush back home.

Joseph is portrayed as a rough man who yells, gets frustrated with God and seems to perpetually be in a bad mood. At the same time, he is effeminate, with nothing in him of the “just man” of the Gospels. This portrayal is gravely insulting to the Foster Father of Christ.

The ‘race’ to Bethlehem

When King Herod receives the Three Wise Men at his palace, he displays a false curiosity about this new King of whom they speak. Then he literally forces the Three Kings to take rest at his palace while he sends out a single hunter and his two dogs to find Mary and kill her.

The dogs duly lead the hunter to Mary and Joseph’s abode, but they have already left for Bethlehem, leaving Bo the donkey behind. After realizing the hunter’s plan, the "hero" Bo convinces Dave the dove that they need to get to Mary and Joseph before the hunter does, and off they go to save the day. On the way, they befriend a sheep named Ruth who is also following the star and she joins the team.

Camels
Meanwhile, the Three Kings are released from Herod’s "hospitality" and sent on their way to Bethlehem. But their shrewd camels – more astute than the wise men, it seems – have discovered Herod’s cunning plot to use the Three Kings to track where the new King will be born. They too plan to get to Bethlehem before the hunter does to save the Mother and her Child.

This chaos, which includes some additional and unnecessary scenes added for comedic and entertainment value, turn the sacred story of Christ’s Birth into a fast-paced and goofy adventure story, stealing all of its splendor and glory.

The Birth of Christ

In one scene, Mary begins to weep because she realizes that fulfilling God’s will not be easy and that scares her. This disgraceful scene make the serene and unwavering Virgin of the Gospels seem to doubt God and disdain His Will.

Eventually, Joseph and Mary – aided by Bo and his friends – make it to safely to Bethlehem. The plot gets quite complicated at this point: Suffice it to say that Bo is captured by his owner the miller (who happens to be in Bethlehem) and is locked inside a stable. In this stable, Bo decides to pray to God as he has seen Mary do it. He then finds more talking animals who reveal to him a manger upon which the star light shines, and the donkey realizes that this is the place to which Mary should be brought. So it is the donkey that finds the stable for Joseph and Mary…

birth
After more adrenaline-inducing scenes, Bo manages to get Mary – who is suffering great pain, another error – and Joseph – who is frantic – into the safe stable. He and his friends then fight off the hunter who falls to his death from a cliff, but they save the hounds who are set free.

The movie ends with all the animals returning to the stable to see the Baby Jesus born.

It is only when the Wise Men bring the Christ Child gifts that Bo realizes he has borne on his back a King and that this child “is special.” He places his head on Mary’s lap and smiles contently knowing he has saved their lives.

In short, by now it must be clear that The Star (2017 ) is anything but a good Christmas movie. Far from being faith-based, the production is, like so many other children’s movies, deprived of any seriousness, with talking animals who are more clever than the people. This movie , however, is more dangerous than others because it teaches children an adulterated history of Chris's Nativity. The Holy Family is portrayed as "funny" and flawed side characters in this Nativity story, with God nearly nonexistent throughout.

This movie adds to a long list of Christmas movies that prudent Catholic parents must avoid showing their children. I am reminded of the verse in Scripture: Which of you, if your son asks for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a snake? (Mt 7:9-11). With this film, you are giving your children stones and snakes…

Share

Blason de Charlemagne
Follow us



Posted November 16, 2026
Related Topics of Interest
Related Works of Interest


A_civility.gif - 33439 Bytes A_courtesy.gif - 29910 Bytes A_family.gif - 22354 Bytes